What Are You Really Eating? The Hidden Problem of Seafood Mislabeling

Marsha Sakamaki • October 3, 2026

Short notes on health, aging, and prevention.
No noise. No selling. Ever.

Get TWC Health Notes

Share this Resource:

Why the name on a menu matters for your health, your wallet, and the choices you want to make.

Shopper examining a seafood label at a fish counter, with the question “What fish is this?”

When you order fish, you make a decision based on a name. You may choose it for its flavor, its price, or what you have learned about its health benefits. You may also care about where it came from and how it was caught. All of those decisions depend on the fish actually being what you think it is.


Once a fish has been cut into a fillet, breaded, or served with sauce, you have much less to go on. The label becomes your connection to information you cannot see. If that connection is wrong, even a thoughtful purchase can lead somewhere you did not intend.


This has been found right here in Honolulu


A study published in 2020 used DNA barcoding to examine 75 fish samples from restaurants, grocery stores, and sushi bars in the greater Honolulu area. Researchers found that 21% were mislabeled. Swai was the most common substitute, appearing under names including red snapper, sea bass, and mahi-mahi.


That finding describes the samples in that study. It does not establish today's rate across Hawaiʻi. The researchers also cautioned that comparisons between locations can be misleading when studies sample different mixtures of restaurants and stores.


Still, the local finding gives us a concrete reason to ask questions. This is a problem that has been documented in familiar places where people buy meals and groceries.


A legal name can still leave you guessing


There are two issues worth separating. One is substitution: selling one species under the name of another. The FDA identifies selling less expensive fish as red snapper as an example of economic fraud.


The other is a name that covers several species. It may meet labeling requirements while leaving out information you would find useful. Here in Hawaiʻi, ʻahi commonly refers to both yellowfin and bigeye tuna. Asking which one is being offered gives you a more precise starting point.


The Honolulu researchers also identified conservation concerns hidden beneath generic, acceptable market names. A broad name can obscure the species even when the label does not count as mislabeling. “Is this label allowed?” and “Does this label tell me enough?” are different questions.


The consequences can reach beyond the price


Paying a premium price for a lower-cost substitute is the most obvious loss. It also interferes with your ability to decide what is worth buying. A less expensive fish may be perfectly welcome on your plate when it is honestly identified and priced.


Species identity can matter for health, too. Escolar and oilfish contain indigestible wax esters that can cause oily diarrhea and abdominal discomfort in some people. Hong Kong's Centre for Food Safety has documented complaints after fish labeled as cod were consumed. Cooking or freezing does not break down those wax esters.


Mercury is another reason identity matters. If you are choosing fish using species-based advice, a substitution can undermine that choice. It does not mean every mislabeled fish is hazardous, but it means you cannot reliably apply advice to a species you have not actually identified.


What can you ask at the counter?


You do not need to become a fish identification expert. Start with questions that make the seller's description more useful:


  • What species is this? If the answer is ʻahi, ask whether it is yellowfin or bigeye. If it is sea bass, ask which kind.
  • Where was it caught or raised? Ask about the harvest location, especially if buying local matters to you.
  • Is it wild-caught or farmed? This helps describe the product and gives you information for any sourcing research you want to do.
  • Can you check the supplier's label? When a menu gives only a broad name, the restaurant may have more detail in its purchasing records.

A person at the counter may need to check rather than know immediately. The useful distinction is whether the business can find a specific answer and is willing to provide it. Asking also tells sellers that identity matters to their customers.


What labels and appearances can tell you


A whole fish retains identifying features that a fillet has lost. That can help someone who knows the species, but it does not make every shopper an expert. A familiar-looking fillet or an attractive display is not proof of identity.


Traceability certification can add useful oversight. The Marine Stewardship Council's Chain of Custody system tracks certified seafood through the supply chain and uses checks that include DNA testing. It provides an additional reason for confidence, rather than a guarantee that mistakes never occur.


Buying locally can give you more opportunities to ask who caught the fish and where. The value is the information you can obtain and verify. A local label alone does not establish the species or the sustainability of a particular catch.


Make your next purchase more informative


Start with a fish you buy regularly. Find out its species, then use that information to look into the health or environmental questions that matter to you. Once you have a clear answer, it becomes easier to compare prices and recognize when another seller is offering something different under a similar name.


You should be able to enjoy seafood without having to investigate every meal. Clear identification is part of what you are paying for, and a specific question can help bring that expectation into the conversation.


October 2026 Update: New Laws Target Seafood Fraud


Consumers have long faced a problem when buying seafood: How can you know whether the fish you're purchasing is actually what the seller claims?


Two recent developments could help answer that question.


In July 2026, Hawaiʻi began requiring certain retailers selling raw processed ahi to disclose the country where the fish was landed. Then, on October 20, 2026, the federal government enacted the Illegal Red Snapper and Tuna Enforcement Act.


The federal law directs agencies to develop a standardized chemical-testing method to help determine the geographic origin of red snapper and certain tuna species. The goal is to create a portable test that enforcement officers could use to identify illegally caught or falsely labeled seafood, potentially even after it has been prepared as poke, sushi or sashimi.


This approach addresses a different part of seafood fraud than DNA testing. DNA can help identify what species a fish is, while the proposed chemical testing would help establish where it came from. Both questions matter, but answering one doesn't necessarily answer the other.


The technology still needs to be developed and validated. Federal agencies have two years to report on their progress.


Why does this matter to consumers?


A label tells you what a seller claims. An independent test could help establish whether that claim is true.


That's an important distinction. Better labeling gives consumers information, but better verification gives that information credibility.


For Hawaiʻi consumers, these developments also offer the possibility of distinguishing locally caught ahi from imported fish more reliably, while helping legitimate fishermen compete fairly.


Sources: Hawaii News Now, October 2026 | Federal legislation, S. 283 | Hawaiʻi Department of Agriculture and Biosecurity



Sources and further reading

Note from Marsha

Note from Marsha


I am interested in the gap between what a label tells us and what we think it tells us. We can put considerable thought into choosing food and still be missing information that changes the decision.


Living in Hawaiʻi makes this seafood question particularly relevant to me. I would like asking what we are buying to feel like an ordinary part of shopping, with useful answers readily available.

Where You Might Want to Go Next

Hawaiʻi Safe Food Guide
Knowing which fish you bought is one part of the picture. Explore practical guidance on handling, refrigeration, poke, prepared meals, and leftovers in Hawaiʻi’s warm climate.


What Do Food Labels Really Mean?
Take a closer look at familiar food claims and what they actually tell you. Learn which details help you compare products and which questions a label may leave unanswered.


TWC Health Notes
Continue exploring health, aging, and prevention through short notes that connect information with everyday decisions and questions you may want to investigate further.


Share This:

Staying in Charge When AI Is Part of Everyday Life, with five numbered steps from pause to ask for a
By Marsha Sakamaki • November 12, 2026
You can stay in charge of AI answers and suggestions. Five plain steps: pause, check, choose what to share, adjust, and ask for a person.
A woman speaks with a clinician who listens; a tablet and paper chart sit on the desk between them.
By Marsha Sakamaki • November 8, 2026
Interviews with 87 women revealed medical records that left out misdiagnoses and mistrust. Learn how gaps in the chart may affect AI and patient care.
Person reviewing health insurance paperwork after a denied medical claim.
By Marsha Sakamaki • October 13, 2026
When health insurance denies care or payment, patients face more than medical bills. Explore the financial, emotional, and practical costs of fighting back.
Light-wood infrared sauna cabin with a glass door; shelves of folded towels stand beside it.
By Marsha Sakamaki • October 11, 2026
Explore how infrared sauna relates to skin health through circulation, heat response, sweating, research, and changes Marsha has observed in herself and clients.
Older woman in her late 60s lifts a light dumbbell during a seated strength exercise in a bright hom
By Marsha Sakamaki • October 11, 2026
Learn how creatine supports muscle energy, what research shows about strength in older adults, and what to know about dosing, weight changes, kidney tests, and more.
Person applying white cream to their cheek, with more cream visible on their forehead, nose, and chi
By Marsha Sakamaki • October 7, 2026
Care for aging skin without complicated routines. Learn how gentle cleansing, moisturizing, and sun protection support your skin's comfort and protective barrier.
By Marsha Sakamaki • October 7, 2026
When health guidance changes, learn to separate new evidence from policy and funding decisions, and ask questions that help you judge what changed.
Older Asian woman beside an illustrative lung scan, highlighting gaps in lung cancer screening eligi
By Marsha Sakamaki • October 7, 2026
Explore why some women fall outside lung cancer screening criteria, what newer research reveals, and how medical recommendations differ from Medicare coverage.
Older woman practicing acoustic guitar while reading sheet music in a sunlit room.
By Marsha Sakamaki • October 5, 2026
Discover how cognitive reserve supports brain resilience, with six practical ways to strengthen thinking and support cognitive health as you age.
Glass bottle of golden castor oil beside castor beans, leaves and seed pods.
By Marsha Sakamaki • October 5, 2026
Explore 42 castor oil uses for skin, hair, castor oil packs, massage and digestive support, with research, tradition and practical guidance.